BLOG, DRIVING OFFENCES

What is the Minimum Sentence for Death by Careless Driving?

At DPP Law, we understand how traumatic it can be to be involved in a car accident that leads to someone’s death, especially if this happened because of a momentary lack of focus and attention. Although causing death by careless driving is a serious offence, it is important to understand how it differs from causing death by dangerous driving, which is a much more serious offence that can lead to life imprisonment. In this article, our team dive into the sentencing guidelines, explaining the minimum sentence for death by careless driving.

Our team of expert motoring law solicitors is here to explain what ‘’death by careless driving’’ means and how this offence is prosecuted in the UK. From penalties and mitigating/aggravating factors to the importance of seeking early legal advice, we are here to help you navigate the stressful legal road ahead.

What does ‘’Death by Careless Driving’’ Mean?

Also known as causing death by inconsiderate driving, the offence of causing death by careless is covered under the Road Traffic Act 1988. Section 2B establishes that death by careless driving occurs when a person causes the death of another by driving in a manner that falls below the standard of a reasonable and competent driver and fails to consider other road users. This means that for the offence to take place it is not required to establish intent to cause harm or a deliberate decision to engage in bad driving, all that is necessary is a short lapse of judgment that has tragic consequences.

Examples of careless driving include:

  • Smoking or eating while driving
  • Being distracted by other passengers
  • Overtaking on the inside
  • Middle-lane hogging

Causing death by dangerous driving on the other hand, is a more serious offence that requires a driver to fall far below the standard expected of a careful driver. This often involves a conscious decision to ignore motoring laws and a clear disregard for the risk of danger to other road users. Because of this, the penalties for death by dangerous driving are far more severe and can even lead to life imprisonment.

What is the Minimum Sentence for Death by Careless Driving?

The primary concern of people charged with death by careless driving is usually the potential prison sentence, but for minor offences this can potentially be avoided. The minimum sentence for this offence is a community order, according to the Sentencing Council for England and Wales but the severity of the penalty varies in relation to the driver’s level of culpability.

The sentencing guidelines set out three categories for determining culpability:

  • Category A (high culpability): driving that was just below the threshold for dangerous driving.
  • Category B (medium culpability): for cases where the error/distraction could have been avoided.
  • Category C (lesser culpability): what is considered a minor and momentary lapse of concentration.

This offence carries a mandatory driving ban of at least 12 months and, depending on the circumstances, can carry a prison sentence of up to five years if the case is heard in the Magistrate’s Court. However, if the case is heard in the Crown Court the maximum prison sentence is 6 months.

What factors affect the sentence?

When deciding on the appropriate sentence, the judge may also consider several other factors that can either increase the severity of the sentence (aggravating factors) or reduce it (mitigating factors).

Aggravating factors that can lead to a harsher sentence include:

  • Previous convictions for other motoring offences
  • Causing the death of more than one person or seriously injuring others
  • Committing other offences at the same time (e.g. failing to stop)

Mitigating factors that can lead to a lesser sentence include:

  • A guilty plea can often reduce the sentence by one to one-third
  • Evidence of genuine and profound remorse
  • No previous convictions and good character
  • Providing assistance at the scene and cooperating with the investigation
  • The actions of the victim or a third party that contributed to the collision

How is this Offence Prosecuted in the UK?

The legal process for a death by careless driving sentence can often be lengthy and complex. The initial police investigation following the fatal collision can take several months as the police gathers evidence like witness statements, CCTV footage and expert reports. The case is then passed to the Crown prosecution Service (CPS) which decides whether to bring a charge.

As this is a triable either-way offence, it can be heard either in the Magistrates’ Court or the Crown court. But usually, the case will start in the Magistrates, and if the case is serious enough it can be sent to the Crown court.

Can You Avoid Jail for Death by Careless Driving?

It is possible to avoid a prison sentence for death by careless driving, as long as the level of carelessness is considered to be very minor, and there are no significant aggravating factors.

In cases where the driver has shown genuine remorse, has a clean driving record and their actions were not deliberately reckless, courts are likely to impose community orders or suspended sentences instead of immediate imprisonment.

Why Early Legal Representation is Crucial

Causing death by careless driving is a serious offence that kicks off a complex legal process that can result in severe penalties, so seeking early legal representation from a solicitor is not just advisable, it is essential. If you’ve been involved in a fatal collision, you should contact a criminal defence solicitor immediately after the incident.

Our dedicated criminal defence solicitors at DPP Law have extensive experience dealing with such cases and we can help:

  • Protect and uphold your rights during the police investigation
  • Examine the prosecutions’ evidence to determine if the legal test for ‘’careless driving’’ or ‘’causation has actually been met
  • Build a strong defence, potentially instructing collision reconstruction experts to challenge the police’s findings
  • If a conviction is unavoidable, argue for the lowest possible sentence by highlighting all the relevant mitigating circumstances

Get in touch with our dedicated motoring solicitors

Our specialist death by careless driving solicitors are here to help you navigate each step of the complex legal road ahead, right from the moment you are asked to attend a police interview down to the final court hearing for your charges.

At DPP Law, our dedicated motoring solicitors can help you reduce, or avoid entirely, any charges that you might be facing. With a proven track record and over 35 years of experience you can rely on us to protect your licence, your freedom and your future.

Get in touch with us today for your free, no-obligation initial consultation by calling 0333 200 7207. Alternatively, you can submit your enquiry via our email [email protected], or by filling out our web enquiry form below.

We’re Driven to Defend you.